American Idol

I was just thinking about the winners of American Idol and I wondered if the winners who sell the most CDs are really the favorites. In my opinion Carrie Underwood is the best, but I want to know what everyone else thinks. source

He could be a good replacement for Simon Cowell, but he would have to want to do it, and not for money. He would have to be motivated to actually do the Job properly not just being in the lime light. How ever based on what I know of his personality, I don't think he would be able to stick with it. source

I think she realizes that American Idol has run its course and is no longer relevant. Prime example of this, David Cook's non-existent career. source

I will miss Paula, but I love Ellen and think she would be great! That new gal Kara bores me, they need someone with a sense of humor to balance out Simon. source

He was on it 5 years ago and I don't find it unbelievable that he's a big fan of the show, but a bigger joke that people think it's all beneath his cool cred to do the show. The man repopularized Neil Diamond and John Travolta in his "masterpiece" for fuck sake. source