|
I am about to do a close study of this year, and am ALREADY having trouble narrowing my supporting actress line-up to 5! What an amazing year this seems to have been for supporting ladies!
Which of my personal nominees would you choose?
Who wins for you...
Started by CeciliaTallis on
, 15 posts
by 12 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at awardsdailyforums):
Http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLyYYHqVTsE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLyYYHqVTsE
Toni Collette, The Sixth Sense
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7ahIGLNNwo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7ahIGLNNwo
Cameron Diaz & Catherine Keener, Being John Malkovich... .
|
|
Quote: : Subsequent performances prove that she's not a very fluid or naturalistic actress.
Someone hasn't seen Margaret ... "Show me a hero and I'll write you a tragedy." - F. Scott Fitzgerald
Started by ksrymy on
, 15 posts
by 14 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
(I think she's a terrible....
And I resented her bigfooting into this category and denying a genuine supporting actress the slot history, a more deserving supporting actress for a foreign-language movie, the talented Gong Li .
|
|
I'm on the Mariel Hemingway train. A spontaneous, deeply-felt performance from an actress whose work I've always found unconventional (though this was certainly a case of pitch-perfect casting). Damien's assessment was spot-on.
Started by mayukh on
, 15 posts
by 9 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
Cite seem like stronger bets than Supporting Actress, though, of course, Woody has always had a lot with supporting actresses at the Oscars is a fact - not only those who were nominated or those who won it was Maureen Stapleton....
|
Ask your Facebook Friends
|
I am glad to see some posters have come out in support of Rinko Kikuchi's performance, because I found her work revelatory upon watching Babel. I didn't spot a trace of sensationalism in her work, and it was by far the most authentic thing about this ...
Started by mayukh on
, 15 posts
by 10 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
Doesn't Monty Woolley is why I prefer the term "performance,"... .
My vote goes to her.
That leaves the field to Barraza, an excellent actress with an oscar caliber performance.
supporting at all, having shared the honors with Dench in NOAS.
|
|
I voted for Helena Bonham-Carter. Her quick, snappy presence completely changes the rhythm of the whole film, and I always enjoy watching such an intelligent actress as herself navigate such "safe" territory as this (similar to Tilda Swinton in Michael...
Started by mayukh on
, 15 posts
by 14 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
And while it is very cool that an actress the supermarket scene, are overplayed....
I also / The Ghost Writer
I've only seen Weaver from the lineup .
Either way, a wonderful performance.
You could also argue she's a supporting actress.
|
|
Nothing compares to Debra Winger's cameo in Rachel Getting Married. It's a real example of what an immensely talented actress can do with a few minutes of screen time – her presence influences the whole film and our insight into the main character's psychology...
Started by mayukh on
, 15 posts
by 15 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
They're both very good....
Edited By Hustler' has.
She gets my vote.
Her sister James is tender and adorable.
SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Hiam Abbass, The Visitor
Amy Adams, Doubt
**Rosemarie DeWitt, Rachel Getting as an actress since Junebug.
|
|
Weiss was fine and Williams worked very hard and succeeded in having us remember her good work.
Leagues better was Catherine Keener, who created a living character from a real person and had us notice her though she was rarely doing anything of note on...
Started by nightwingnova on
, 15 posts
by 14 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
Cheered even louder for Amy Adams, who I think gives the greatest supporting actress performance-Supporting-Actress" go, Rachel Weisz probably isn't the less talented, though I was never deeply with Maria Bello over Frances....
|
|
Zeta-Jones gets a tough part perfect, but is not spectacular.
Latifah, I find not connected to the culture of the times. Worse, she's performing a lot rather than "acting."
Strangely, I don't remember much at all about Bates' performance.
Started by nightwingnova on
, 15 posts
by 12 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
And second an unfulfilled adult....
Is Lilly Koshashvilli, and she actually won the best Supporting actress at the Israeli Ophirs (along a lead as Kidman was, and took a spot here that could have gone to a true supporting actress.
|
|
My choices:
1. Rosamund Pike, in "The Libertine"
2. Kirsten Dunst, in "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind"
3. Lynn Redgrave, in "Kinsey"
4. Daryl Hannah, in "Kill Bill: Vol. 2"
5. Anne Heche, in "Birth"
ALT: Amanda Seyfried & Rachel McAdams, in "Mean...
Started by bizarre on
, 15 posts
by 15 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
In each case, I did like the actress more than I ever had before but 1) not at such a level in a movie I like a great deal, but she'....
I'd been told I would see a revelatory advance from an actress who'd up till then not been impressive.
|
|
Ronan and Dee were both good/decent.
Swinton had virtually no character to work with but filled her performance with delicious eccentricities. She shone.
Better was Amy Ryan, who took a showy role and played it beautifully with tough sass layered in subtleties...
Started by nightwingnova on
, 15 posts
by 15 people.
Answer Snippets (Read the full thread at cinemasight):
I would usually....
Blanchett does picks, one can't complain when they choose one of the most original and interesting actress working support.
One of my favorite supporting-actress performances of the whole decade.
For Amy Ryan.
|
